Registered Charity no: 278266
© 2008 Otter Valley Association

The Carved Bench-ends of All Saints Church, East Budleigh C16

The Carved Bench-ends of All Saints Church,

East Budleigh C16

 

The sixty carved bench-ends in All Saints Church, East Budleigh are predominantly of the Renaissance, though some have elements of late medieval style.  One is dated 1537, a typical date for them all(1).  

 

 

 

The 15th century saw a widespread intellectual reawakening in Europe stimulated and fed by the mass products of the new movable metal type presses.  There was a curiosity about the world generated by contemporary voyages of discovery, advances in mathematics, cartography and navigation, a rediscovery of classical art and literature and the questioning of religion. The Copernican revolution in astronomy that profoundly changed perception of man’s home in the universe had also begun.  Some of this is apparent in the images on the bench-ends.

 

From early in the 15th century, as sermons became an important element of worship, fixed seats began to replace stools in churches.  It was easier to follow the argument sitting.  The All Saints bench-ends adorn what would have been the first fixed seating in the church.

 

1537 was in the midst of the Reformation following the first step towards underpinning the insecure Tudor dynasty. The Queen had not born the requisite legitimate male heir. Henry VIII was persuaded that re-marriage was the only way forward.  In 1527 the pope was petitioned to annul his marriage. 

 

Before he was elected Pope Clement VII (from 1523-34), Cardinal Giulio de Medici had been the principal minister responsible for papal policy.  He had also been cardinal protector of England, the monarch’s “ambassador” in papal councils.  De Medici had had a long and close relationship with Henry VIII; he promoted papal evaluation of Henry’s refutation of Luther’s critique of the seven sacraments and secured for him the papal accolade “Fidei Defensor”.  Henry would have been confident of the success of his petition.

 

His confidence was misplaced.  The pope was constrained from an early favourable decision by Canon Law forbidding the granting of a second annulment to Catherine.  Moreover the pope, who had already been imprisoned during the Hapsburg occupation of Rome in 1527, was threatened with a renewed military attack on Rome by the naval forces of the Emperor Charles V to deter any papal agreement to annul his Aunt Catherine’s marriage.

 

By 1532 Henry’s patience was exhausted.  He married Anne Boleyn triggering excommunication in 1533.  Catholic rulers were now obliged to depose Henry and there was a risk of the preaching of a crusade against England. The Act of Supremacy, establishing the Church of England with the King as head was passed the following year.  

 

Monasteries were Dissolved in 1539 and All Saints Church was confiscated from Polsloe Priory.  Warm feelings boiled over in 1549 when Rebellions against the new prayer book broke out.  Exeter was besieged by rebels for two days.  Two thousand died in the suppression of the rebellion after battles at Clyst St Mary and Woodbury Common. 

 

However none of these feelings, nor any aspect of religion appears in the imagery of the bench-ends.  It embraces modernism, the Renaissance fascination for classical culture and iconic threats of the Dark Ages.  A celebration of land and mercantile wealth is juxtaposed with a discovery of Ovid's concept of Metamorphosis with transgressing humans punished by transformation into plants by offended gods and with the Romayne heads and bestiaries from Roman villas of classical culture.

 

The well-to-do rented the best seats to appraise the sermon, at the chancel end of the nave, where the images on eleven bench-ends reflect land or mercantile wealth. 

 

The dated bench-end is on one of the two pews of the Ralegh family(2).

 

 

 

Walter Ralegh senior, a young Exmouth ship-owner who settled in East Budleigh when he married Joan Drake of Littleham in 1518, was one of the most prominent Protestant reformers in Devon.  As churchwarden, he was responsible to the bishop for implementation, in East Budleigh, of the provisions of the new Church of England.  In 1549, the year of the Western Rebellion he was kidnapped by Clyst St Mary rebels before rescue by Exmouth mariners(3).  The defacing of his shield on the bench-end may reflect some unpopularity at this time.  Ralegh continued trading from Exmouth until at least 1552(4).

 

Another mercantile-related bench-end shows an armed merchant ship.

 

 

East Budleigh had been a busy medieval port with international trade and ships serving the crown.  However centuries of longshore drift of shingle across the mouth of the River Otter with progressive accumulation of silt upstream constricted shipping and finally closed the port to all but coastal traffic and fishing around 1470(5).  Shipping operations were moved to Exe ports(6), though ship-owners continued to live in East Budleigh during the 16th century(7). (See als: OVAapedia article The Ship Carving of All Saints Church, East Budleigh)

 

Pictorial evidence suggests the ship had been a foreign prize captured in some past naval battle and bought by an East Budleigh man in the last decade of the 15th century to be re-fitted for a trading venture to North Africa(8).  It was too large for the Otter estuary(9).  The owner used one of the Exe ports(10).

 

Another carving on a cloth merchant’s pew contains elements of the arms of the Company of Weavers and Fullers of Exeter.

 

 

 

Some fifty other seats for reserved for the general public rather than a particular family.  They are scattered throughout the nave.  About thirty have foliate designs

 

 

 

with the free-flowing sinuous vegetative shapes characteristic of renaissance styles.  Several feature metamorphosis into or from animate shapes such as dolphins or a crocodile,

 

 

 

and fabulous creatures inspired by bestiaries on newly found Roman villas that were influencing renaissance fashion.  These include a dragon

 

 

 

and a fishy monster,

 

 

 

which would have reminded the carvers of the threatening mythical creatures of the Dark Ages such as the wodewose

 

 

 

brought to England by the Saxons; his descendant, a green man mask

 

 

 

worn by an actor dressed in leaves in morality plays; and his cousins, boggarts

 

 

 

threaten from plants.  The carvers seem to have been unabashed by the mythological horrors that terrified Dark Age people and have a playful view of them.

 

Other carvings warn transgressors of metamorphosis as a punishment for their behaviour. The tongue-sticker

 

 

 

has been bearing false witness, gossiping or talking in church.  A woman in a conch is emerging from sin.

 

 

 

Also on general seats for families are a cook

 

 

 

with her early turnspit dog and an animated widow.

 

 

 

 

Three pictograms of mariners decorate seats for the unmarried men (two illustrated).

 

 

 

 

Researched and written by David Jenkinson, © 2010

 

References:

 

(1)      T.N Brushfield The Church of All Saints, East Budleigh. Part II ; Transactions of the Devonshire Association (Trans. DA) no. 24, 1892

(2)      Brushfield Notes on the Ralegh Family; (Trans DA) no. 15, 1883

(3)      Brushfield 1883

(4)      When he provided passage to exile in France for Sir Peter Carew then fomenting opposition to Mary I’s marriage to Philip. See Brushfield Notes on the Ralegh Family, 1883

(5)      Leland’s Itinerary, 1530-40, reported this to have been earlier than in living memory

(6)      Matthew Andrew’s Ottermouth ship James was involved in a dispute about cargo in London in 1474 (Gardiner West Country Shipping no. 89).  He built a new ship, James  of Topsham in 1482 to benefit from Henry VII’s remission of tax on first voyages of new ships (PRO c76)

(7)      The Lay Subsidy (Tax) Rolls 1524 (T L Stoate, 1979) record several Budleigh residents excused tax because of goods lost at sea.

(8)      Friel The Good Ship (Johns Hopkins, 2005)

(9)      By inference from a comparison of the main parrel with that of the Mary Rose

(10)    By inference as suggested by the Exeter Castle in the carving. 

 

EB-G-00007 89 Raleigh